Saturday, May 17, 2008

The Insanity Of The Iraq War and "Appeasement"

From James Carroll at the Boston Globe:

Insanity is defined as repeating one mistaken action again and again, each time expecting a better result that never comes. Prime example: the United States in Iraq. Washington perceived a weapons of mass destruction threat from Saddam Hussein, but instead of responding with diplomacy - internationally coordinated weapons inspections - it went to war. When Saddam Hussein was toppled, the initiative should have passed from the Pentagon to a State Department-led program of stabilization and reconstruction, but instead a crudely violent military occupation was begun. Diplomacy was once again rejected.
....

Let's call this repeated insanity the mistake of "supermilitarism," choosing war over diplomacy, and expecting order to follow, instead of chaos. The mistake was made at the beginning, in the middle, and is being repeated now, in what should be the end. The mistake is so deeply rooted in American structures of imagination, economy, and government that it isn't even perceived as a mistake by those in power. And it threatens the future as much as it burdens the past.
....

The occupation is the mistake that keeps on taking.

The healing of Iraq would be far more readily achieved by an American acknowledgment of failure, and by the engagement of other nations that such an acknowledgment would immediately invite. But insanely holding on in Iraq until Washington can claim something like "victory" means that this globally oriented geo-political ambition - America's standing in the world - is being bought at the price of Iraqi blood.


And now Barack Obama is being Swift-Boated by the president himself in a foreign country and by John McCain for wanting to try diplomacy with "rogue nations" before launching wars. Remember Bush's Axis of Evil, Iraq, Iran, and North Korea? Well, according to CNN, Bush is negotiating with North Korea:

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The United States said Friday it has reached a deal with North Korea to provide 500,000 metric tons of food aid over the coming year to the closed-off communist nation.

The Bush administration says the aid is unrelated to its nuclear disarmament deal with Pyongyang, although both have involved an unusual intensity of U.S. diplomacy with a nation President Bush once included as part of a rhetorical "axis of evil."


Obama is being accused of "appeasement" by ignorant or deceptive people who do not know or care what the word means. Using diplomacy with leaders of other nations is NOT appeasement. Will the American people buy this ugly smear? We shall see.

9 comments:

  1. JFK said "We should never negotiate from fear, but we should never fear to negotiate".
    If Obama can drive this home, he will be okay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I feel ill - how I loathe the fear card.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sen. Obama is handling it all brilliantly. To my delight, he acts and speaks as though the American people can reason and understand. Granted, that may be overestimating us but it is SO refreshing, especially in contrast with the New England idjit (who pretends he's from Texas) lecturing us as though we were all as simple as he.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Why should we expect our leaders to stop this war? It's not as if it costs them anything.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think Obama has handled all of this quite well. The only different approach that I would suggest, brilliant political strategist that I am, would be to have more surrogates out there to handle the nitpicking criticism, so that he's not bogged down in responding to the small stuff and can concentrate on the large issues that most people care about.

    Johnieb, you're right, although Bush gave up his beloved golf game.
    Talk about sacrifice!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Friends of ours just heard that their son is coming home next week afters 2 years in Iraq. They are limp with joy. That's the good news. The bad news is that he'll probably have to go back in six months.

    This war is obscene.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Elizabeth, thanks be to God that he's coming home. That he will be sent back in six months is horrible, indeed. I hate this war.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The GOP wants people to believe that the US has to behave like a bully, and that if we don't keep up an appearance of always being strong, it's an admission of weakness. They don't seem to understand that bullies are bullies because they feel weak, and that if you are truly strong, you don't need to appear strong all the time--that in fact, if you need to always appear strong, then you are admitting weakness.

    What got me today was seeing comments on GOP blogs not quite gloating over Sen. Kennedy's seizure or stroke, and harping that he has the blood of one woman (Mary Jo Kopechne) on his hands. These same people feel it's a sign of righteousness that GWBush has the blood of over four thousand American soldiers, and Allah-alone-knows how many Iraqi soldiers and civilians, on his hands. I guess being a President absolves a person of any guilt for homicide.

    Please pray for Sen. Kennedy; we're obviously going to need him in the Senate for a long time to come, I think.

    Oh, btw, Paul--don't you dare call President Bush a New Englander. I was born there, and the less connection I have to him, the better. Texas can have all of him.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Kishnevi, that's exactly right. If you're secure in your own inner strength, you don't feel the constant need to prove your toughness.

    The Fox people were obscene about Kennedy. No matter about the 4000 dead and thousands of wounded Americans and God knows how many thousands of Iraqis. The Republicans put me in mind of King Kong beating his chest.

    Yes, Kennedy needs our prayers.

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous commenters, please sign a name, any name, to distinguish one anonymous commenter from another. Thank you.