"Where's the gratitude?"
From Pat Buchanan's "A Brief For Whitey" in Human Events in March 2008:
Barack says we need to have a conversation about race in America.
Fair enough. But this time, it has to be a two-way conversation. White America needs to be heard from, not just lectured to.
This time, the Silent Majority needs to have its convictions, grievances and demands heard. And among them are these:
First, America has been the best country on earth for black folks. It was here that 600,000 black people, brought from Africa in slave ships, grew into a community of 40 million, were introduced to Christian salvation, and reached the greatest levels of freedom and prosperity blacks have ever known.
[Jeremiah] Wright ought to go down on his knees and thank God he is an American.
Second, no people anywhere has done more to lift up blacks than white Americans. Untold trillions have been spent since the '60s on welfare, food stamps, rent supplements, Section 8 housing, Pell grants, student loans, legal services, Medicaid, Earned Income Tax Credits and poverty programs designed to bring the African-American community into the mainstream.
Governments, businesses and colleges have engaged in discrimination against white folks -- with affirmative action, contract set-asides and quotas -- to advance black applicants over white applicants.
Churches, foundations, civic groups, schools and individuals all over America have donated time and money to support soup kitchens, adult education, day care, retirement and nursing homes for blacks.
We hear the grievances. Where is the gratitude?
Whew! The piece was a tough read, I can tell you. The "Silent Majority" ruled for only 8 years. That wasn't nearly enough time for them to have their voices heard and to have their way. My heart bleeds for downtrodden hetero white men. They don't get no respect. No one listens to them. Minorities and women rule!
From Pat's latest, "Miss Affirmative Action, 2009" on Sonia Sotomayer in Human Events:
No one has brought forth the slightest evidence she has the intellectual candlepower to sit on the Roberts court. By her own admission, Sotomayor is an "affirmative action baby."
Though the Obama media have been ballyhooing her brilliance -- No. 1 in high school, No. 1 at Princeton, editor of Yale Law Review -- her academic career appears to have been a fraud from beginning to end, a testament to Ivy League corruption.
Two weeks ago, The New York Times reported that, to get up to speed on her English skills at Princeton, Sotomayor was advised to read children's classics and study basic grammar books during her summers. How do you graduate first in your class at Princeton if your summer reading consists of "Chicken Little" and "The Troll Under the Bridge"?
I must conclude that all of Sotomayer's professors colluded in grading her work through her undergraduate years to boost her to her summa cum laude degree and her award as one of the two outstanding graduates at Princeton for her year. And the reason she was chosen as editor of the Yale Law Journal was not because she merited the position, but because the Journal needed a poster Hispanic girl.
To me, it seems that the assistence that Sotomayer received along the way did what it was supposed to do, helped her excel through her own efforts and hard work. Of course, I could be wrong.
Okay, so we all know that folks with racist and anti-feminist views dwell amongst us. Human Events has the right to publish despicable drivel. But why does Buchanan have a reserved seat as a commentator on matters conservative at MSNBC, a major cable news channel? No doubt Pat is well-compensated for occupying his chair and blathering on and on with his idiocies. He exercises restraint on MSNBC, because he knows where his bread is buttered. Is Buchanan an example of what the cable channel thinks of as balanced opinion presentations?
H/T to Zachary Roth at TPM Muckraker.
"Miss Affirmative Action 2009"? And Clarence Thomas?
ReplyDeleteThe nasty drivel you have to stand on TV...
ReplyDeleteClarence Thomas? Now there a shining star in the firmament of the Roberts court! He never says a word, or so I hear, and simply does whatever Scalia tells him.
ReplyDeleteGöran, indeed, the things we must endure. Thank goodness for the off switch.
What an ass!! I am not going to read anything else by him if I can help it. I almost didn't get any further that the 3rd paragraph, and then I read on. No not willingly will I read another word. I think I am going to be sick.
ReplyDeleteI would be shocked, but I hear this kind of talk around my neck of the woods all the time. I still say he and those like him are like the south side of a north bound mule. Folks here I pitty because it's how they were raised. Bucky there knows better.
ReplyDeleteI'm with susan s. Skimmed only, once I realized it was Human Events tripe.
ReplyDeleteI used to chuckle at Eventer reasoning and opinion. But that was years ago before these crazies inspired some really sick people to take up arms and murder innocent people. I no longer view this madness as entertaining, because the fallout is just too darn serious.
I've even taken down some of my "Know Thine Enemies" listings on my blog, because I no longer think it safe to give them any voice whatsoever.
Thanks, Mimi, for the reminder that folks like these Eventers consider themselves TEH intelligentsia of the right---yikes!
Some years ago the late William F. Buckley published a small book that concluded that Mr. Buchanan is (or was then) anti-Semitic. Mr. Buckley was certainly no liberal!
ReplyDeleteI think if one were to re-visit the criteria Mr. Buckley used, and make a similar analysis today one would conclude that Mr. Buchanan is a racist and anti-Hispanic.
MSNBC inter alia have to be somewhat 'representative' or else the screams start and the mail begins. I suppose in a purely cynical analysis we might conclude Mr. Buchanan fills a lot of slots for them. Anti-latino, racist, misogynist, and anti-Semitic all while smiling and using pretentious 'intellectual' language. There are not that many who can fill that bill. After all, our African arch-bishops are generally not racists. Some of their manipulators may be another matter entire, but this way the network gets the whole package.
FWIW
jimB
I think I need to read:
ReplyDelete[Jeremiah] Wright ought to go down on his knees and thank God he is an American.
a little more carefully, but maybe 'God is a [white] American' is the subtext..
I fail to understand why MSNBC thinks having a racist, anti-feminist, anti-semitic type represent the conservative vewpoint is a good thing.
ReplyDeleteRajm, suspect that there is a subtext to everyting Buchanan speaks or writes,unless he expresses his prejudices plainly.
That should be "I suspect". I'm on a crappy computer with a bad keyboard.
ReplyDeleteI still say he and those like him are like the south side of a north bound mule¨ AH
ReplyDeleteWhy can´t I say things like that? You know, nice ways of putting things instead of just blurting out As* H*le! I think it´s that Southern Fried Hospitality...you folks really know how to oooze it out with a little smile instead of a snear.
'Suspect you're right about subtexts, Mimi. Remember that Buchanan cut his teeth as a speechwriter for Dick Nixon. He's still nothing more than a glorified propagandist. I don't think even he believes half of his venomous punditry.
ReplyDeleteBut JimB is absolutely correct: Buchanan's masterful as token smiling misogynist, xenophobe, racist, and anti-Semite. Personally, if I'm sure not too many folk are eavesdropping, I love the catharsis of screaming insults at the TV screen when Pat is on his game.
Why can´t I say things like that?
ReplyDeleteLeo, that particular gift is reserved for Arkansas hillbillies.
Crapaud, there is that consolation prize.
One summer I was working at a youth camp in the kitchen. As I was cleaning up the dining hall (that overlooked a lake in the Sierra), I stooped to scoop up what I thought was spilled mustard with my bare hand. It was baby poop.
ReplyDeleteNow why does reading Buchanan make me think of that episode?
Sickening. Purely sickening. (And I DON'T mean the baby poop.)
ReplyDeletePaul, the leap seems perfectly logical to me.
ReplyDeleteAh, Ellie, hang in there, love.
But Grandmère - think what Buchanan's done to people on my end of the Christian political spectrum!! For years we've had to work hard to be sexist and homophobic - now we're supposed to be racist as well??? Does the man think it's easy being objectionable?
ReplyDeleteAnd doesn't he realize my beloved Consuella will kill me if I try and keep up with him on this front???
At least he hasn't spilled the real secret: the lead up and subsequent result of the last election proves the Silent Majority is neither...
Fr Christian! It's always an honour to have you visit.
ReplyDeleteI'm afraid that you are in a bind - if you know what I mean.
Mimi, I nearly gagged when I read it this evening. All I can say is ARGH!
ReplyDeleteAmelia, we need to know what's out there under the rocks.
ReplyDeleteMr. Buchanan must be well-versed in "testament[s] to Ivy League corruption" and academic careers that "have been a fraud from beginning to end" -- after all, he obtained a Master's in Journalism from Colombia.
ReplyDeleteNow I just have to remember how to spell "Columbia".
ReplyDeleteWell Paul, I think it would asking far too much for Pat Buchanan to be logical.
ReplyDeleteAs for your spelling, you were close. That's something.
Reverend Wright should be glad nobody's paying attention to him or any other 'preacher'.
ReplyDeleteBuchanan probably still misses Franco.