Wednesday, October 13, 2010

HOW MANY DEATHS WILL IT TAKE...? PART 6



From Eric Reitan at Religious Dispatches:

More often than not, conservatives represent the internal Christian debate over the ethics of homosexuality as if it were between those who hold firm to traditional Christian values and those who have sold out to secular culture. But this way of framing the debate ignores the real motivations of progressive Christians like myself—motivations that spring from real human tragedies.

The other day a young gay man in Oklahoma took his own life. This is not a new or even an unusual occurrence, although it comes in the wake of a string of highly publicized suicides by young gay men, suicides blamed on bullying. But Zach Harrington’s suicide last week highlights the fact that for sexual minorities in America, the problem runs much deeper than overt bullying, at least as that term is ordinarily understood.

Zach attended a city council meeting in Norman, Oklahoma, during which three hours were given to the public to express their views as to whether GLTB History Month should be recognized. In the end, the proclamation was approved, but the debate:

...became an occasion for those with the most hateful views to be handed a microphone and afforded the chance to tell the community just how sick, sinful, perverted, and disgusting their gay and lesbian neighbors are. According to the Tulsa World report, Harrington’s father “said he feels his son may have glimpsed a hard reality at the Sept. 28 council meeting, a place where the same sentiments that quietly tormented him in high school were being shouted out and applauded by adults the same age as his own parents.”

There you are. The bigotry and hatefulness goes beyond the school years, which is no surprise. Why would we be surprised that some LGTB persons:

...internalize this condemnation. They accept the message that their deepest impulse towards love and intimacy is an affront to God. And since that impulse is an ineradicable feature of who they are, some come to see their very existence as a blight on the world.
....

Sometimes this sense of isolation and rejection can be almost too much to bear, and all it takes is a final gesture of denunciation or scorn to spark an act of self-obliteration.
....

Jesus said that we should distinguish true and false teachings by their fruits. And the teaching that homosexuality is a sin—that, in the words of the Southern Baptist Convention, even the desire for homosexual sex is “always sinful, impure, degrading, shameful, unnatural, indecent and perverted”—this is a teaching that time and again has born poisonous fruits. The shattered promise of Zach Harrington’s life is just one more example in a painful litany.
....

Any theory of the Bible that requires me to ignore my neighbors in favor of teasing out the correct meaning of Romans 1:24-27 seems to do an injustice to the Bible’s heart. If there’s a core message to the Christian Scriptures, it’s that Jesus—a person, not a book—is the fundamental revelation of God. It’s Jesus that John’s Gospel calls the “Word of God,” not the Bible. And in the Gospels, not only does Jesus say nothing about homosexuality, but He is recorded as saying that He comes to us in the form of the neighbor in need—“even the least of these” (Matthew 25:37-40).

I'm going far beyond fair use of another's words, but the essay says so much that is right and true that it's difficult to stop quoting Eric Reitan's words. I urge you to read the entire essay.

But can you really have the right theory about a book if the book teaches you to love your neighbors as yourselves, but your theory about it demands that you stifle the character traits most intimately associated with love? If your theory about the Bible leads you to ignore or refuse to hear the suffering cries of your gay and lesbian neighbors, wouldn’t that be a reason to rethink your theory? Put more forcefully, how many gays and lesbians, crushed by the weight of anti-gay teachings, have to kill themselves before we decide that, just maybe, our theory about the Bible isn’t the best fit with the idea that God is love—and hence isn’t the best fit with the content of the Bible itself?

So what then do we do? We take note and honor those who have died by trying to save GLTB young people and adults from being driven to such desperation that they decide to end their lives. We publicize such organizations as The Trevor Project, which offer help to those who feel there is no hope for productive, happy, and fulfilling lives.


src="http://www.youtube.com/v/5RKmnAJ3ZWM?version=3" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" allowScriptAccess="always" width="640" height="390">

Chris Colfer shares a very personal message for LGBTQ youth in response to the recent suicides that have occurred: "I know what it's like to be bullied and teased every single day and I know that it may seem like there is no chance of happiness left. But I promise you, there is a world full of acceptance and love just waiting for you to find it. So please before you take a drastic action that could be your last, call The Trevor Project."

Just this morning, I told one of my readers, Jerry, that I couldn't write any more about gay suicides, that after Matthew Shepherd's anniversary yesterday, I was empty, that I had no more words for the heartbreaking stories, and here I am a couple of hours later writing again. I want not to write any more of these stories. I want the numbers on the "How Many Deaths Will It Take...?" series of posts to stop increasing, because the deaths stop. That's what I want.

Thanks to Cathy for the link.

22 comments:

  1. Thank you, Mimi. This is what I was trying to get at in the comments to my short thought on homophobia. It is toxic, destructive and deadly. Just because it comes from "religion" is no excuse. That only makes it worse.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Without wanting to presume too much here, I think I get why Zach thought: "What the hell is the point of even going on?" Far too many ****ing idiot bigots are given a microphone in the interests of "fairness". Enough. It really stinks.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm convinced that the Church will perish on its own homophobia.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it's time for we the church to start making videos. We need to speak out beyond our own circles and put the message out there that there are Christians who are informed by a Gospel of love and hope and inclusion and that we care about actual people. It appears that most of the secular world believes that Christians only care about parsing certain verses and an ideology of "morality" that has nothing to do with love, with feeding the hungry and standing with the outcast. There are plenty of us who operate under this standard but apparently the word still hasn't gotten out. Maybe we need to be working harder to get that word out.

    ReplyDelete
  5. We need to work a hell of a lot harder. How, I don't know.

    ReplyDelete
  6. hence isn’t the best fit with the content of the Bible itself

    I don't think the Bible HAS a "content" (that that in itself is a bill of goods sold by those who want to CONTROL the Bible's "content").

    The Bible has CONTENTS (plural). All of which can ONLY be viewed subjectively, by each and every reader/hearer.

    Once I understood that---the Bible was ONLY what *I* saw in it (in dialogue w/ others, of course---but not subject to someone else's control: no Pope's, no Southern Baptist Convention's, no televangelist's . . . no ABCantuar's!)---then I discovered a Bible which could illuminate (both by what it said, AND what it didn't).

    And I learned to love Scripture ("Read, mark, learn and inwardly-digest").

    Using the Bible to control, discriminate, Power-Over?

    Anathema!

    Using the Bible to harrass, oppress, KILL our children?

    NEVER AGAIN!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Maybe we need to be working harder to get that word out.

    Penny, I agree.

    ReplyDelete
  8. JCF - I so, so agree.

    wv - mater!!

    What ho, mater, what's for afternoon tea, what??!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. If there’s a core message to the Christian Scriptures, it’s that Jesus—a person, not a book—is the fundamental revelation of God.

    Amen!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Grandmere Mimi is our mater, and beloved of God.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Cathy, how lovely.

    Sadly, the first thought that popped into my head was:

    She had so many children, she didn't know what to do;

    But I won't do as the old woman who lived in a shoe. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ah, Mimi, you know, the Mad Priest has previously compared you to the Old Woman Who Lived In A Shoe. Perhaps you should embrace your destiny? ... :-)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Well, if it was a nice shoe and roomy....

    ReplyDelete
  14. Indeed. If the shoe fits ...

    wv - quorid. "Really, she thought, life wasn't so quorid"

    ReplyDelete
  15. Everything said here is true and certainly enough was said by alleged Christians at the Norman, Oklahoma, public hearing to push Zach Harrington --- and other youngsters without harder shells --- into suicide. Those who spoke hatefully bear a share of the responsibility for his death and I expect them to be judged for that.

    There were, however, hopeful signs during the hearing (I watched all two-plus hours of it online). Alhtough about 20 people spoke against the resolution (fewer than half hatefully), 24 people spoke for the resolution in eloquent and moving ways. Only two I believe self-identified as religious --- an especially eloquent Unitarian Universalist and a United Methodist pastor. No Episcopalians identified themselves as such.

    When it came time for council member comments, two spoke at length, one very movingly, about why they had decided to vote against what seemed to be the majority sentiment in Norman and for the resolution. All other council members and the mayor affirmed their words, including the dissenting council member who implied that he felt he should represent majority opinion rather than his own.

    I'm pointing this out only because I think we need to be careful about demonizing (because we're often demonized) an entire community like Norman on the basis of the actions of only some of its residents. I also hope that those of us who preach often to the choir online or elsewhere will when the opportunity arises stand as public witnesses as those who backed the LGBT History Month resolution in Norman did.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think we need to be careful about demonizing (because we're often demonized) an entire community like Norman on the basis of the actions of only some of its residents.

    Hi Frank. Thanks for visiting and leaving a comment. If I gave the impression in my post of demonising a whole community, I'm sorry, for that was not at all my intention. After all, the resolution passed, which is all to the credit of the political leadership in Norman and the folks in the city who spoke movingly in favor of the resolution.

    In the end, the proclamation was approved....

    ReplyDelete
  17. No, no --- no criticism of anything you have written was intended. It was a tendency I've noted elsewhere but commented on here. I've been moved, amused and sometimes prodded (but never offended so far as I can recall) by "Wounded Bird" for a long time.

    ReplyDelete
  18. There are good and brave people everywhere, even in Oklahoma, says this native Texan.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I've been moved, amused and sometimes prodded (but never offended so far as I can recall) by "Wounded Bird" for a long time.

    What kind words. Thank you, Frank!

    Counterlight, just look at you! A living miracle out of Texas!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hearings require an open mic for fairness, I suppose, but it's way past time for the media to learn that the humanity of lgbt people -- my humanity -- is not an issue on which there must always be presented the lies of hateful bigots in the name of fairness.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Paulas, I agree with you about the media. The "side" of hateful bigotry should be presented as what it is - hateful bigotry.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hearings require an open mic for fairness, I suppose, but it's way past time for the media to learn that the humanity of lgbt people -- my humanity -- is not an issue on which there must always be presented the lies of hateful bigots in the name of fairness.

    WORD, paulas.

    If these sort of statements were said about African-Americans or Jews or Catholics, that "open mic" would SO be unplugged, PDQ!

    *Only* w/ LGBTs very lives are subject to this kind of "on the other hand" OPEN BIGOTRY. Enough! >:-0

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous commenters, please sign a name, any name, to distinguish one anonymous commenter from another. Thank you.