Sunday, January 9, 2011

QUOTE OF THE DAY - FEAR OVER REASON

"It's very hard to unscare people.... [P]eople are far more compelled by their fears than by their reason." (Dr Paul Offit)

As Athenae at First Draft reminds us, it's not just Sarah Palin, and I add, Glenn Beck, and their ilk, who speak out in public forums in misleading or outright false statements, laden with militaristic references and imagery, with the intention to promote fear and deep distrust amongst the American people, but also those who supply the money, some of whom prefer to remain in the background, out of the limelight:
It's about the people who fund the tea party and every other ultra-right-wing movement in this country.

Jane Mayer in The New Yorker writes at length about the billionaire Koch brothers, David and Charles:
In Washington, [David] Koch is best known as part of a family that has repeatedly funded stealth attacks on the federal government, and on the Obama Administration in particular.

Bear with me as I take a detour to address an article in USA Today which concerns the study that linked certain vaccines for children to autism, which has since been proved to be "an elaborate fraud," but which nevertheless caused, and still causes, many parents to avoid having their children vaccinated.
Last year, The Lancet issued a formal retraction. British medical authorities last year also found the study's lead author, Andrew Wakefield, guilty of serious professional misconduct, stripping him of his ability to practice medicine in England.

Now, the BMJ (a British medical journal) reports that Wakefield, who was paid more than $675,000 by a lawyer hoping to sue vaccine makers, was not just unethical — he falsified data in the study, which suggested that children developed autism after getting a shot against measles, mumps and rubella.

Vaccination rates fell in Britain and the US, leading to outbreaks of measles in Britain and Ireland, which caused many children to become ill and even a few deaths. Paul Offit, a pediatrician at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, says:
...it may take years to rebuild trust in vaccines. "It's very hard to unscare people. You can do study after study, but people are far more compelled by their fears than by their reason."

Now, turn your attention to the myths and falsehoods promulgated about health care reform:
1: There is no health care crisis

2. Health care reform will impose rationing

3: Health care reform provides for euthanasia, "death panel"

4: Health care reform legislation will cover undocumented immigrants

5: Health care reform will raise your taxes

Cont....

Altogether, Media Matters lists 15 myths about health care reform. Read the rest at their website. No matter how many facts were offered to those who spread the falsehoods around, they persisted in their beliefs(?) and their versions of "the facts".

Which leads me back to my quote for the day. Slightly edited, Dr Paul Offit's quote applies to the political situation in the US today"
"It's very hard to unscare people.... [P]eople are far more compelled by their fears than by their reason."

Thanks to Canon Alan Perry, who blogs at Insert Catchy Blog Title Here, who called my attention to the quote. He applied the quote to the situation today in the Anglican Communion, where it seems just as pertinent. Dr Offit's words seem very wise to me.

OFF TOPIC UPDATE: Alan Perry has a series of excellent posts on the Anglican Covenant which are well worth reading.

9 comments:

  1. Interestingly, someone is attempting to smear Jane Mayer by accusing her of plagiarism. The accusations are unfounded. She is a distinguished journalist but apparently speaking truth to power is causing someone some consternation.

    This is America in 2011. THis is what we've come to.

    ReplyDelete
  2. IT, how despicable. I've been reading Jane Mayer's articles in the New Yorker for years, and I've found them excellent, without exception. The brothers appear to wish not to be known as supporting the tea partiers. Are they ashamed?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Glenn Beck 2008-2010: "Don't trust Obama! Don't trust currency---BUY GOLD!"

    Jared Loughner 2010 (via YouTube): "Don't trust the government! Don't trust currency not backed by gold!"

    ...and then in 2011, Jared Loughner ACTED on those (insane-in-the-membrane) FEARS.

    ReplyDelete
  4. JCF, none of us should forget that words have consequences, too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is all pretty scary and horrible stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes, words have heart-rending consequences. The silence of folks of good will also has consequences.
    No one can accuse you, Grandmère, of being silent, but I am certainly examining my own quietness and conscience, in my blog writing and in my heart.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Laurel, I often feel like a voice crying in the wilderness, but as the quote by Fr Roy Bourgeois on my sidebar says, "Silence is the voice of complicity." Whether my voice does any good at all is beside the point.

    Indeed, "Sir".

    Why am I calling you "Sir"? I'm older than you are.

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous commenters, please sign a name, any name, to distinguish one anonymous commenter from another. Thank you.