From Josh Marshall at TPM:
Obama isn't saying the right thing. He should be saying, "Stop lying." Or maybe he should send Biden out to say it. That's probably the best thing.
I'm not basing this on some misguided sense that being aggressive is what's required. Rather, I'm basing it on how the MSM works. They report what politicians say. And they don't fact check them. That's the system -- maybe you don't like it. I don't like it either. But it's not changing any time soon.
That's a key point, so I'm going to repeat it. All the broadcast MSM does is report what politicians say. They don't fact check them. Afterwards, they have blowhards sit around in panels and have disingenuous spin-meister discussions about whether or not what was said is playing well with the general public.
And the public option is probably dying a slow, painful death.
From the New York Times:
PHOENIX — The White House, facing increasing skepticism over President Obama’s call for a public insurance plan to compete with the private sector, signaled Sunday that it was willing to compromise and would consider a proposal for a nonprofit health cooperative being developed in the Senate.
The “public option,” a new government insurance program akin to Medicare, has been a central component of Mr. Obama’s agenda for overhauling the health care system, but it has also emerged as a flashpoint for anger and opposition. Kathleen Sebelius, the health and human services secretary, said the public option was “not the essential element” for reform and raised the idea of the co-op during an interview on CNN.
So. There we are. And I find it quite depressing.
I do too. Very depressing. I think, in light of this fear and anger and opposition that we ought to stop all Federal health care programs, including to the Senate and Veterans and medicare and medicaid.... if its too risky for all, it is certainly too risky just for some.
ReplyDeleteSorry Grandmere --I'm venting....
Yes. It's all crap. I'll wager a number of those shouting at the town meetings are on Medicare or the VA plan.
ReplyDeleteVent away, Margaret.
Obama has repeatedly shown that he will not take up a fight. He isn't a politician, he's a visionary.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, I don't need a vision, I need health care.
Josh, I'm afraid you may be right.
ReplyDeleteI believe it was Tobias Haller who said that Obama may live too much in his head, like someone else we know, and that does not necessarily make for good governance.
DEpressing!
ReplyDeleteVery depressing. I remember when I was told, in no uncertain terms, that the USA is a "Christian nation". Explain that statement in light of our treatment of the have-nots in society?
ReplyDeleteI'm with it's Margaret: if the federal government is so inept at health care, then it's time to take away benefits to ALL who are currently receiving federal care.
The adminestration looks like a former congress person runs it. I am betting on Rhom Emmanuel. If they want to pass something, they need to work with a single member or a senator and come up with a comprehensive draft. Then the president can get behind it and push. "Calling for" a bill gets you 5 (in this case, more in others) and lets your opponents pick you off on the details. That is exactly what happened.
ReplyDeleteFWIW
jimB
I'm with you all the way FWIW.
ReplyDeleteRight at this point, I'd rather see no bill than a crap bill. If a crap bill passes through Congress and is signed into law, the president and Congress may be lulled into thinking that they have actually done something for the citizens of the country who need help so badly.
ReplyDeleteQuick! Someone tell Obama about the bully pulpit!