Thursday, January 27, 2011

SNIDE JOURNALISM

Earlier today, Lapin sent me the link to this particularly nasty bit of snide journalism by Damian Thompson in his blog at the Telegraph:
The Most Rev Katharine Jefferts Schori, presiding bishop of the Episcopal Church, has given a most revealing interview to the Houston Chronicle in which she says that Anglican churches in Africa have polygamous members and, um, that’s basically OK. I mean, not ideal, but a man can keep his wives if he wants to, though not add to his collection.
....

Well, I suppose her Church was founded by a man with six wives…

Here's the Q&A from the Houston Chronicle:
Q: How does that play in more conservative parts of the world? Do you follow one set of beliefs here, and other cultural values in other parts of the world?

A: That's really the name of the game with Anglicans. One of our primary issues during the Reformation was that worship had to be in a language the people could understand. We take context really seriously, because we take incarnation, the presence of God in the flesh, very seriously. He appears to us in different ways in places. I'll give you a contrasting example. In the 1980s, the Anglican community started to wrestle with the issue of polygamy in Africa. Polygamy is not an issue here, except in very small pockets of Utah and Arizona, and the church has taken a very different position. We said no. In Africa, the church doesn't officially recognize polygamy. They certainly have polygamous members of their churches. In some places, they say the man can't take additional wives once he becomes a Christian, but he isn't forced to divorce the wives he already has. The children generally are recognized as full members if they want to be baptized.

In some instances, there was good reason for permitting married, male converts to Christianity to keep the wives they already had. Had the wives and children been abandoned, many of them would have been viewed as outcasts in their societies, women with no status, left without protection.

Obviously, Thompson doesn't do nuance well. Thompson is Roman Catholic. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

52 comments:

  1. Actually, "her Church" was founded by the daughter of a man with six wives.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Correct, Lapin. And Thompson knows better, but he couldn't resist the dig. As though his church always does him proud.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a pathetic journalist this is. Instead of "Telegraph" he should write for the "Clanging Cymbal"

    ReplyDelete
  4. And check Tobias' comment on Episcopal Café - on the Lambeth resolution re: polygamy

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ann, I read Tobias' comment just now, but I didn't copy, or I would have given him credit. My post was up first. :-) I like to give credit, where credit is due, but I remembered enough of the resolution to write the words in my post.

    Tobias is correct. Thompson could have Googled and found the resolution in seconds.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I did not think your were plagiarizing- just thought "great minds"

    ReplyDelete
  7. Obviously, Thompson is not a member of our "great minds" group.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Not only is he a Roman Catholic, he is also the most snarky of British Columnists. He's also an ass in my opinion. I like to think that at least Henry didn't have 6 wives all at once. Yes. I know 2 of them were executed, but we all make mistakes. . . except of course for Mr. Tompson.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh no! I misspelled his name! Horrors! I do notice that his first name is spelled the same way as the 'spawn of the devil' character in all the "Omen" movies. Hmmm. . .

    ReplyDelete
  10. Susan, the same thing (re his name) occurred to me. His picture does look a little demonic, but who am I to talk...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh dear! I'd spelled Damian's name wrong, which may be the greatest offense I've committed against him in the post. I corrected my mistake.

    susan and Tobias, if your comments were a kind way of calling my attention to the mistake, I thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Tobias, you don't look a bit demonic, although you once had a photo....

    ReplyDelete
  13. I was believing your spelling, Mimi. I was ready to accept it because of my prior feelings toward Mr. Thompson. I still agree that he looks demonic. Or maybe it's just that superior attitude that he exudes from every hair on his head!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Yes. I know 2 of them were executed, but we all make mistakes

    Susan, is there something you would like to tell us? ...

    ReplyDelete
  15. susan, Damian strikes a pose in his photo. The question is, what message does he send by his pose? And does he, in fact, send the message he wishes to send?

    Cathy, you would not want to dig around in susan's back yard.

    ReplyDelete
  16. My dinner caught spectacularly on fire while I was typing the above comment. I mean when I went in the kitchen there were flames coming out the oven. Is there a moral in that?...

    ReplyDelete
  17. Ah, anyway, the Torygraph is a rag, and has only got worse in recent years, in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I know what the message is! It's Queen Liz I communicating with me from the afterlife pointing out that she would have had Damian Thompson burned at the stake.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Is there a moral in that?...

    Cathy, I'm afraid so. The Omen.

    I hope the fire is out.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Cathy, I was referring to Our Lord, when he said something to the effect of "Let him without sin cast the first stone."
    I'm sure we all have some . . . sins, that is.

    Mimi, my back yard is not big enough in which to bury bodies.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Mimi, my back yard is not big enough in which to bury bodies.

    Not even one?

    ReplyDelete
  22. Oh go on, Susan, tell us. Who have you had bumped off? ... And was the cyanide in the violet creams?

    ReplyDelete
  23. You can use mine, Susan. We could always use more compost.

    Remember: Friends help you move; real friends help you move bodies.

    ReplyDelete
  24. It was the mutton chops that caught on fire, if anyone is interested. Sheep fat burns very easily, I fear. I should have kept my eye on them.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Remember: Friends help you move; real friends help you move bodies.

    Exactly!

    ReplyDelete
  26. I fear. I should have kept my eye on them.

    Indeed, Cathy!

    ReplyDelete
  27. As to burial, there's always cremation, which is a great space saver. I'm taking advantage of it in my "pre-planning" (which I always just call, "planning.") Maybe we could borrow Cathy's oven?

    Mimi, the missing picture was due to my not having actually logged in...

    ReplyDelete
  28. Re the message sent by Damian Thompson's "pose", Cathy, Fr Orsen Carte opens his post on this topic with the observation "Fanny Thompson is causing mischief on his gay RC blog". Maybe this helps?

    ReplyDelete
  29. Lapin, I think Cathy was looking for a message from beyond about why her Mutton Chops caught on fire.

    Your answer fits with Mimi's observation about Mr. Thompson's pose.

    I have heard the "Fanny Thompson" reference before. BTW, what is Fr. Carte's blog address? Or does he have a column in a more reputable paper?

    ReplyDelete
  30. Out of respect to Mimi I did not link Fr Carte, Susan, but his blog name is "Anglican Mainstreams". Not that this is "Mainstreams" with a final "s" - omitting it and you will land in a totally different world.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Yeah, why did my mutton chops catch on fire???

    I blame Damian Thompson.

    I ate them anyway (the chops). They were extremely good. If a bit BBQ-ey.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Maybe we could borrow Cathy's oven?

    Tobias, you would be welcome :-)

    ReplyDelete
  33. Oh yes, Lapin. That guy. Definitely don't link to him.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Better than some I can name, Susan. I post there pretty regularly.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Cathy, I was going to ask about the mutton chops, if they were edible, but I see you answered before I asked.

    For supper tonight, Grandpère brought home sloppy roast beef po-boys with gravy, lettuce, and tomato, which were delish.

    ReplyDelete
  36. One of my comments disappeared. I had to be away from the computer for a while, and I thanked you all for behaving yourselves and not linking to naughty websites on my child-friendly blog while I was gone.

    So, is Damian gay, then?

    ReplyDelete
  37. Damian gay? All we know is that some think so and that they get away with saying it, Mimi.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Dear all

    Since I live in South Africa, I'll make bold and comment on this.

    The person who works for me is the first wife of a man who is married to two wives.

    Both women are devout Christians, and both are regular attendees of an AIC (African Independent Church) in our area.

    In recent times in South Africa, and despite the behaviour of President Zuma (which is generally regarded as irresponsible, by the way), the practice of polygamy is becoming less common - partially as a result of urbanisation and partially, of course, because it is so expensive.

    A man who was a member of a mainline church (Anglican, RC, EO, Baptist, Presbyterian) would be told "you can't marry a second wife here". And only some AICs allow polygamy, and then only reluctantly. As the presiding bishop says (in effect), cultural realities are what they are.

    Damien Thompson's remarks are the product of a man who is not as well informed on ecclesiastical matters as he should be, and who would be well advised to worry about the state of his own church rather than problems elsewhere.

    Jane Smith (Pretoria, South Africa)

    ReplyDelete
  39. For some reason, the following comment did not appear here. It came through in my email that shows new comments but did not show up on the blog. I thought you all should see the comment.

    smithj1@unisa.ac.za said:

    Dear all

    Since I live in South Africa, I'll make bold and comment on this.

    The person who works for me is the first wife of a man who is married to two wives.

    Both women are devout Christians, and both are regular attendees of an AIC (African Independent Church) in our area.

    In recent times in South Africa, and despite the behaviour of President Zuma (which is generally regarded as irresponsible, by the way), the practice of polygamy is becoming less common - partially as a result of urbanisation and partially, of course, because it is so expensive.

    A man who was a member of a mainline church (Anglican, RC, EO, Baptist, Presbyterian) would be told "you can't marry a second wife here". And only some AICs allow polygamy, and then only reluctantly. As the presiding bishop says (in effect), cultural realities are what they are.

    Damien Thompson's remarks are the product of a man who is not as well informed on ecclesiastical matters as he should be, and who would be well advised to worry about the state of his own church rather than problems elsewhere.

    Jane Smith (Pretoria, South Africa)

    ReplyDelete
  40. To be fair to Damian Thompson, if I read him aright, it's just a snark. It's not meant to be deep or accurate - he's just having a go. Even so, I think Jane should go to the Torygraph website and leave her thoughts on the matter as a comment.

    ReplyDelete
  41. PS Mimi, I've always wanted to taste an oyster po-boy. A roast beef po-boy sounds good too, from the way you describe it.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Well Blogger, it's one fine mess you got me into. Blogger has begun to screen spam, and Jane's comment was in my spam folder. I'll have to remember to check my spam folder when the comments don't appear and mark them "not spam".

    Jane, your excellent comment is now posted twice. Thank you for weighing in. Yours is a voice that we need to hear.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Cathy, then Damian must take his licks for his snark. I know I do. :-)

    A Louisiana oyster po-boy is to die for. Tom had a take-out oyster po-boy today. I had a plate of fried oysters, which were very good, too, along with tasty tartar sauce and coleslaw to go with them.

    ReplyDelete
  44. oh yes absolutely, he has to take licks for it, but he is writing on the understanding that his readers will realise his comments are in a sense careless just for the sake of it (I think).

    I love tartare sauce and any seafood you can match with it. Your meal sounds extremely yummy.

    ReplyDelete
  45. That should read "take his licks" btw :-)

    I do have a recipe for oyster po-boys. I should run it by you, Mimi, to see if it's the real thang.

    ReplyDelete
  46. The Po' Boy originated in London, not Louisiana, Cathy.

    ReplyDelete
  47. I'm sure you're right, Lapin, but the only recipe I have offers it as a Louisiana tradition.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Lapin, whence cometh your information about the po-boy originating in London?

    ReplyDelete
  49. Been at a recital of 17th & 18th c English Baroque music. Sorry for the delay.

    "One recipe, for the peacemaker or oyster loaf, originated as a ubiquitous London street food long before the founding of New Orleans in 1718, and a scholarly consensus holds that this New Orleans classic arrived via the Thames. (See, e.g., Grigson 110: “It was taken to America, and became popular in New Orleans, where it acquired the endearing name of la mediatrice.”)" Quote from here. The recipe cited may be found on p 110 of Jane Grigson's English Food.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Lapin, could be. After the Louisiana Purchase, the invasion by the English began.

    Gerald Bodet is mentioned in the article. I wonder if he's the same person who was at Loyola when I was. I see he was still teaching in 2006, but in his online ratings, one of his students says about him, "He is also the cutest older man ever!!!!!!!"

    I hope you enjoyed the concert. It sounds lovely.

    ReplyDelete
  51. It was very good. They had imported (from Up-North) an excellent bass viol player to supplement the home team. Sounds like Bodet could well be your guy. Is Bodet a common surname in those parts?

    ReplyDelete
  52. Good.

    Bodet is not that common a name around here. That's why I believe it may be the same person. He would have been teaching beyond the age of 70.

    ReplyDelete

Anonymous commenters, please sign a name, any name, to distinguish one anonymous commenter from another. Thank you.