BISHOP NICK BAINES SETS US STRAIGHT

From the Guardian:

So, the Dean of St Albans has been "blocked" from becoming the next Bishop of Southwark. Really? Well, the Telegraph has confidently told us so – so we might as well remove our brains and take their word for it. Or not.

What is amazing about this whole story is not just the shameful behaviour of the leaker (who has sworn an oath of confidentiality), but the credulity of many people who have responded (look, for example, at Thinking Anglicans) is depressing. They have accepted the details and language of the story without thinking. And, predictably, the usual suspects from the extremes of the Church were ready with their quotes of indignation and threat.

Well, despite the fact that the bishop did not name me as one who caused him to feel depressed, (almost certainly not having read my posts!) I feel culpable in a you-know-who-you-are sort of way, having devoted three posts to the subject.

In my defense, as I said to Cathy who sent me the link to Bishop Baines column:

Of course, I understand the need for confidentiality during the the process, weeding out those who don't measure up in the background checks, etc. But once the shortlist is decided, why the secrecy? Bishop Baines says because that's what the procedures are in the CofE. But if the names were made public, there would be no need for leaks. What's wrong with suggestions that more transparency might be a good thing?

Bishop Baines then goes on to give quite a helpful explanation of the process of choosing bishops in the Church of England.

Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, head of the English Church, and primus inter pares of the Anglican Communion, has no compunctions about interfering in the internal affairs of the Episcopal Church by lecturing our bishops on how to be bishops nor about warning our church as to which of our candidates for bishop are suitable to be elected and given consents. Why then should it matter if a lowly pew warmer from across the pond, with no power whatsoever to make it happen, suggests a bit more transparency and a bit less secrecy in the procedures for choosing bishops in the Church of England?

Nick Baines is Suffragan Bishop of Croydon in the Diocese of Southwark.

FROM THE COMMENTS...

...to my post "A Time of Reckoning For Rowan?".

Wilfried said...

"What is needed is more transparency over how appointments are made. Obsessive secrecy is damaging the church."

What we said yesterday, but I'll add that transparency and openness is about as English as kidney pie is American. It's like my mother says, who now lives in CA, "They may be pushy and rude, but at least you know where you stand." We consecrate gay bishops because we, the TEC as a whole, mean it, not because some cabal orchestrated it, nor as some political ploy.

"He should realise there are greater considerations, like truth, justice, openness, fidelity to the rules and all those things the church proclaims. Many are dismayed by his constant capitulation to the fringe noisemakers."

Rowan hitched his cart to the wrong horse. He's made an idol of unity at all cost, and sold out everything and everyone else to achieve it, which means pandering those who scream the loudest, and kicking his friends who have always been willing to play ball. The Americans and TEC have never threatened to quit the game and take our ball, and dollars, and go home. However, the ones who had tantrums and threatened to leave if they didn't get what they want are leaving anyway. So, in spite of all his Neville Chaimberlain-esque pandering, he's losing the conservatives. Meanwhile, he's kicked TEC so much that we've simply stopped caring. I read the ++KJS's letter as coming very close to saying, "Do what you will, we're done here, and we're moving on, with you or without you." Mind you, she was the one who personally helped push through B033, just days after her election as PB, at great cost to herself, as an attempt to the dialog open and stay in the game. Despite her efforts she's been repeated vilified, demonized, and insulted, mitergate being only the latest instance, so she ain't gonna stick her neck out for him again. Thus he's also losing the Americans who were trying to play his game. The same is happening in his own CoE, where he's sold out Jeffrey John and women clergy for the same idol. Yes, he sold out his convictions and all sense of fair play in the name of a chimerical unity, and as a result faces losing the whole ball of wax.

"I would not give these stories and commentary nearly so much attention were Rowan not attempting to set up a top-heavy structure resembling the Roman Catholic Church for the Anglican Communion..."

My gut tells me the Rowan is not really power hungry, or trying to play Pope. Rather, he's painted himself into a corner. His ham-fisted attempts at pandering, appeasement, and finger-wagging at the wrong people have earned him less unity, rather than more. In growing desperation he's left with his last resort, increasing authoritarianism in an attempt to impose unity from above. I think is he's a very smart and ultimately sincere man, but with a skillset entirely unsuited to the situation in which he finds himself, and he's floundering and lashing out in all the wrong ways. I'm trying to have sympathy for the man, even as I'm angry at all that he's done.

These thoughts have been rattling around my head for a while, so FWIW I wrote them down here.


Wilfried's opinions are not necessarily my opinions, but they are not necessarily not my opinions. Well done, Wilfried.

HOD PRESIDENT BONNIE ANDERSON TO SPEAK IN DIOCESE OF SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS

Bonnie Anderson, President of the House of Deputies of The Episcopal Church, will be visiting the Diocese of Springfield on Friday, July 23rd at the Decatur Hotel and Conference Center in Decatur, Illinois. She will be speaking on "The Ministry of All the Baptized: the rights and responsibilities of the laity in the leadership of the diocese and TEC."

The Diocese of Springfield is in the process of selecting a new bishop, and Bonnie's visit is sponsored by the group Concerned Laity of the Springfield Diocese (CLSD).

"The Friday evening program provides a rare opportunity to be in the midst of, to hear from, and to enter into discussion with Bonnie Anderson, one of the preeminent laity of The Episcopal Church," sais Chuck Evans, CLSD. "Bonnie's message "The Ministry of all the Baptized" is essential spiritual nourishment for all lay and clergy within the Diocese of Springfield as we move towards the election of a new Bishop and the new paths forward that will inevitable be charted."

CLSD has issued a special invitation to the people of the Diocese of Quincy to join them in meeting with Bonnie. This link will take you to a map of the Decatur Hotel and Conference center. If you plan to stay overnight, you can reserve a room at a special block rate by calling 217-422-8800 and mention the Bonnie Anderson/CLSD event. Bonnie's presentation is at 7:30 p.m. There is a Hospitality Room starting at 6 p.m. (BYOB/F)

This link will take you to a Diocesan website page with pictures of all of the Nominees. If you click on a specific picture the submitted documents supporting the nomination become available. This represents a vast majority of the information included in the Nominee Binder -- the CDs with a video presentation of the answers to the questions is probably the most significant missing piece, according to Chuck.

Bonnie Anderson's website is here.

NEW DICTIONARY DEFINITIONS

These fit so well they should be in a dictionary.

ADULT:
A person who has stopped growing at both ends and is now growing in the middle.

BEAUTY PARLOR:
A place where women curl up and dye.

CANNIBAL:
Someone who is fed up with people.

CHICKENS:
The only animals you eat before they are born and after they are dead.

COMMITTEE:
A body that keeps minutes and wastes hours.

DUST:
Mud with the juice squeezed out.

EGOTIST:
Someone who is usually me-deep in conversation.

HANDKERCHIEF:
Cold Storage.

INFLATION:
Cutting money in half without damaging the paper.

MOSQUITO:
An insect that makes you like flies better.

RAISIN:
Grape with a sunburn.

SECRET:
Something you tell to one person at a time.

SKELETON:
A bunch of bones with the person scraped off.

TOOTHACHE:
The pain that drives you to extraction.

TOMORROW:
One of the greatest labour saving devices of today.

YAWN:
An honest opinion openly expressed.

and MY Favourite!!
=========================
WRINKLES:
Something other people have, similar to my character lines.

Don't blame me. Blame Doug.

OH MY GOODNESS!

From Grand Gallicho at Commonweal:

Everybody relax. As widely expected, Rome is about to issue new rules for handling priests who sexually abuse minors, including those who view child pornography and abuse adults with mentally disabilities, classifying such acts as grave canonical crimes.

Good news! Read the details at the link.

But wait!

Oh, and the new document will include those who try to ordain women and women who try to get ordained.

You can't make this stuff up.

Says Gallicho:

It will be interesting to see how the new norms and their accompanying documentation handle the issue of women’s ordination. Footnote? Bullet point? Boldfaced and highlighted? Whatever the case, why now? To fuel the suspicion that in the 1980s and ’90s the CDF was more interested in disciplining “liberal” doctrinal abusers than it was abuser priests?

The Vatican takes one step forward and I can't even count how many steps backward.

H/T to Andrew Sullivan at the The Daily Dish.

GOOD NEWS - NOT SO GOOD NEWS

From Kansas City.com:

Hours after giving their blessing to ordaining noncelibate gays and lesbians, leaders of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) declined late Thursday to change the church's definition of marriage, in effect refusing to allow same-sex marriages within their denomination.

If the proposal had been approved, the church's definition of marriage would have changed from a commitment between "a woman and a man" to "two people" and allowed church weddings in states that have legalized gay marriage.

That the Presbyterians decided to discuss same-sex marriage for two more years is disappointing, but the "yes" vote for gay marriage will come soon. The train has left the station.

The gay ordination proposal, which did pass, still must be approved by the majority of the church's 173 local "presbyteries," or district governing bodies, within the next year before it can take effect.

Let us pray that a majority of the presbyteries vote to approve the proposal.

H/T to Andrew Gerns at The Lead.

WHAT'S THE POINT?

From WWL-TV:

Gov. Bobby Jindal has signed into Louisiana law an objection to President Barack Obama's signature health care revamp.
The bill by Republican Kirk Talbot — signed by Jindal on Tuesday — declares that no one in Louisiana can be required to have health insurance or be required to pay a penalty if they refuse to carry insurance.

The measure is symbolic, including language that nothing in it should be construed to supersede federal law.

What a waste of the legislature's and the governor's time - passing and signing into law a symbol with no meaning to back it up. A sop to the Teapartiers, I'm sure.

Thanks to Paul (A.), but I'd already read the story but was too lazy to post. I give Paul credit for prodding.

Note: I'm overtaken by lassitude. No telling what you might find here today, including nothing further. ;-)

GOOD NEWS FROM GEORGIA

The state’s Court of Appeals issued a ruling Thursday in favor of the Episcopal Diocese of Georgia and the national church in its two-and-a-half year property dispute with a breakaway congregation.

A three-judge panel upheld Chatham County Superior Court Judge Michael Karpf's 2009 decision naming the Episcopal Church the rightful owners of Christ Church in Savannah.

You may leave the Episcopal Church, but you may not take the property with you.

H/T to Jim Naughton at The Lead.

A TIME OF RECKONING FOR ROWAN?

From Stephen Bates at the Guardian:

Rowan Williams, the archbishop of Canterbury, is embroiled in a new crisis within the Church of England over the decision to block the appointment of a gay cleric as bishop of Southwark.

Liberals and mainstream Anglicans are furious that the archbishop has once more failed to exert any leadership over mutinous forces threatening to split the church over the sensitive issue of homosexuality.
....

One senior cleric said: "The time of reckoning has come for Rowan. The events of seven years ago have bitten him hard in the very week women bishops comes to the crunch. He should realise there are greater considerations, like truth, justice, openness, fidelity to the rules and all those things the church proclaims. Many are dismayed by his constant capitulation to the fringe noisemakers.
....

Another senior cleric said: "The system of appointments is busted. What is needed is more transparency over how appointments are made. Obsessive secrecy is damaging the church."

Giles Goddard, chair of the liberal Inclusive Church movement, who is himself a gay vicar in south London, said: "This is a disaster for the church – another example of shooting itself in the foot. It would be much better to have a more open system."

There's more.

I'm sorry for the turmoil in the Church of England, but, as I've said before, I would not give these stories and commentary nearly so much attention were Rowan not attempting to set up a top-heavy structure resembling the Roman Catholic Church for the Anglican Communion, of which the Episcopal Church is a part. And one can hardly say that he's doing such a great job of leadership in the Church of England that we would want him for an Anglican pope, if we at all wanted an Anglican pope.

And Pluralist strikes again.

Rowanov Treetri: I am afraid there was a problem with a pipe.

John John: What, a smoking pipe, or you called a plumber?

As usual read the rest over there.

STORY OF THE DAY - LIVING MEMORY

I carry you with me into the world,
into the smell of rain
& the words that dance between people
& for me, it will always be this way,
walking in the light,
remembering being alive together

A lovely message for me today.

From StoryPeople.