March 14, 2012
Dear Supporters,
Since I last wrote to you, developments in the progress on the
development of the Covenant have been fast and (occasionally) furious.
We had previously assumed that adoption of the Covenant would come
before General Synod in York this July, and we were concerned that it
might be overshadowed by the – hopefully final – debate on the
appointment of women bishops. But this has almost certainly been
overtaken by events.
Voting has been continuing in the dioceses, the surprise being that the
current state of play is 17 against the adoption of the Covenant, with
only 10 in favour of it. If a simple majority of the dioceses vote to
reject it, the Covenant will not after all be brought before General
Synod. There are 44 dioceses, which means that the pro-Covenanters need
23 to be in favour. Thus to defeat it, we only need to have 22 dioceses
reject it. The Covenant could not be brought before General Synod again
in this quinquennium, i.e. not before July 2015 (and it is hard to see
how it could be revived then).
On 17 March, this coming Saturday, Norwich, Liverpool, St Albans,
Chester and Ely will vote; and on the following Saturday, 24 March, they
will be followed by Lincoln, Exeter, Blackburn, Oxford, Guildford and
Peterborough. You can follow the results on the
Thinking Anglicans
website and also at
Modern Church.
Our experience in the last few months has been that, wherever members of
the diocesan synods are briefed on both sides of the question, they
have tended to vote against the Covenant. In several cases, synods have
refused to allow briefing papers on both sides to be circulated. In
Sodor and Man, Bishop Gregory Cameron of St Asaph debated with Jonathan
Clatworthy of Modern Church before the diocesan synod: despite an
address by the Bishop of Sodor and Man strongly in favour of the
Covenant, it was rejected.
Our team in the Coalition has been strengthened by the recruitment of 5
more patrons: from England, the Revd Dr Diarmaid MacCulloch, Professor
of Church History at Oxford University, and the Revd Canon Sarah
Coakley, Professor of Divinity at Cambridge University; from the USA the
Revd Dr Marilyn McCord Adams, Professor of Philosophy at University of
North Carolina and formerly Regius Professor at Oxford University; from
Australia, Dr Muriel Porter, OAM, a senior Anglican and correspondent
for ‘The Church Times’; and from New Zealand the Rt Revd James White,
Assistant Bishop of Auckland.
Concentration remains, for the moment, on the Church of England.
Professor MacCulloch was interviewed with Bishop Graham Kings of
Sherborne by Edward Stourton last Sunday. You can hear it on
YouTube,
and you can also hear his general comments on the Covenant
here. This
video was fortuitously uploaded to YouTube the day after the Archbishop
of Canterbury’s
rather rambling piece - and appeared to be in response
to it.
So, to summarise, it is possible that by the end of March we will have
defeated the Anglican Covenant, at least in its present form. I never
imagined, when we started the No Anglican Covenant Coalition in 2010,
that we could conceivably achieve this result. It has not happened yet,
so for now our efforts are concentrated on getting at least 5 more
dioceses voting our way. If we succeed, the next task will be to keep a
close eye on what the Anglican Communion Office do next. Will they try
to rescue it in some way or other, or will we have a part to play in
more constructive dialogue about the future of the Anglican Communion?
Thank-you to so many people who have been working hard at the local
level to enable both sides of the debate to be heard. Please continue
your efforts, we still need your help.
With very best wishes,
(Coalition Moderator, the Revd Dr Lesley Crawley)